Informed Consent for Surgery
A 50-year-old woman with menorrhagia from a large uterine fibroid attends the clinic to complete the consent form for an elective abdominal hysterectomy. The surgeon explains the indication, the alternatives, the operative risks and the expected recovery, and the patient asks appropriate questions and agrees. Which of the following is the most important remaining step in the consent process?
- A.Careful listening to her concerns
- B.Clear documentation of the discussionCorrect
- C.Exploration of her emotional response
- D.Introduction to the surgical procedure
Explanation
Valid informed consent has four elements: the patient must have capacity, must be given adequate information about the nature, benefits, risks and alternatives of the procedure, must decide voluntarily, and the process must be recorded. In this vignette the disclosure, questioning and voluntary agreement have all already taken place, so what remains is to document the discussion clearly. Documentation should name the specific procedure, the material risks discussed, the alternatives offered including medical therapy and uterine sparing options, the questions asked, and the fact that the patient agreed. A signed form on its own is not consent; it is only evidence that a consent conversation occurred, and courts and licensing bodies treat contemporaneous notes as the key record. Careful listening and exploring feelings are important communication skills and are part of the conversation that has already happened, not the remaining formal step. Giving an introduction about the surgery has likewise already been completed. Consent for hysterectomy should specifically cover irreversible loss of fertility, bladder, ureteric and bowel injury, bleeding, thromboembolism and the possibility of oophorectomy. Consent must be taken by someone able to perform the procedure or trained in it. Consent may be withdrawn at any time before surgery.
Why each option
- A.
- Careful listening is essential to the consent conversation but that conversation has already taken place in this scenario.
- B.
- Correct. Clear contemporaneous documentation of what was disclosed, asked and agreed completes and protects the consent process.
- C.
- Exploring feelings supports the patient but is not the outstanding formal requirement for valid consent here.
- D.
- The introduction and explanation of the operation have already been given, so repeating them is not the remaining step.
Reference: General Medical Council. Decision Making and Consent. London: GMC, 2020; Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 8th edition. Oxford University Press, 2019.
This is one of 3,009 questions in the MedBoardSA SMLE bank, with timed test mode, tutor mode, and progress tracking by topic.
Practise the full bank